Do the Statue of Liberty’s Words Still Ring True? – The Islamic Dilemma

Immigrants arriving in the United States via New York Harbor

When immigrants arrived to the United States of America via the New York Harbor between the latter half of the 19th to the beginning of the 20th centuries, they were greeted by the Statue of Liberty with the words that represent the American spirit: “Give me your tired, your poor, your huddled masses yearning to breathe free.” Today, however, the U.S. attitude towards newcomers has changed. The American people, as well as Europeans, have shown a growing concern over the obvious metamorphosis of the nature and type of immigration, which they consider a threat to national identity. Theirs is not a position against foreigners preserving some of their cultural or religious traditions in as much as the non-conformist mentality seen from many Islamist immigrants.

U.S. Supreme Court Justice Louis D. Brandeis—a son of Jewish immigrants—said in his 1915 speech on True Americanism that immigrants seeking a home in America needed to do much more than learn English and have good manners. He argued that they “must be brought into complete harmony with our ideals and aspirations and cooperate with us for their attainment.” The influx of Islamists, as we Westerners fear, threatens to reshape the ethnic and religious composition of our nation-states, our democratic-capitalist tradition and our social values.

This concern has been heightened by the fact that many Muslim immigrants have cultivated an autonomous sharia-based society in our homeland, such as in Dearborn, Michigan, where animosity towards Christians has been constant and at times violent. We also see this with the establishment “Muslim-friendly” hotels in prominent places such as Florence (Italy), sharia patrols in German cities, and sharia courts in England. In London alone, there are at least 100 sharia tribunals which parallel the established legal system by which Muslims are free to disavow civil laws and regulations in the private sector. In this sense, Islam has proven remarkably resistant to persistent attempts to relegate it to the private sphere.

Of course, there are many Muslims who seek to flee from the draconian sharia rules in their native countries with the hope of creating a new and dignified life. This is an obligation that is owed to them. At the same time, other Muslims migrate because of the hijra doctrine (patterned on the migration of Muhammad to Medina from Mecca in 622). As compelled by Islamists, including extremist imams and Islamic “rights” activists, they feel it is their duty to leave (or are forced to leave) their homeland in order to spread the kingdom of Allah.

What we face now is a situation in the West which was foreseen by then-Algerian President Houari Boumendienne in 1974. In an address to the United Nations, he stated: “One day, millions of men will leave the Southern Hemisphere to go to the Northern Hemisphere. And they will not go there as friends. Because they will go there to conquer it. And they will conquer it with their sons. The wombs of our women will give us victory.”

Let us keep in mind that a nation has the right and duty to protect and secure its borders. Yet while the fears of Americans and Europeans are valid, the closed-border policy has not solved the Islamist phenomenon, which in the end is a doctrinal one. Regrettably, because of the political correctness in our culture, primarily instigated by the left-wing politicians and philanthropists like George Soros who seek the demise of Western civilization, one cannot even rationally address the Islamist dilemma, lest he or she be accused of Islamophobia.

We should therefore not be surprised when Islamists in the West collectively refuse to assimilate, nor should we be startled that inadvertently at least, we have politically capitulated to their demands. The American Founding Fathers, notwithstanding their misgivings, gave us more than a voice before government — they gave us the right to elect government officials whom we must hold responsible. And because this governmental system has been adapted by the entire free world,  we all have a duty and a responsibility to safeguard and promote our freedom before a malignant aggressor. Yes, as Thomas Paine once said: These a times that try men’s souls. Let us not be distraught by the opposition, but rather, with the help of the Almighty God, be motivated to safeguard and promote our freedom not just for ourselves but for our children’s children. 

N.B. This article was originally published by the Clarion Project on December 18, 2019, with some additions to the final paragraph, as well as the subtitle.

I invite everyone to please take a look at my book Islam: Religion of Peace? The Violation of Natural Rights and Western Cover-Up. Everything you wanted to know about Islam and what you can do to keep it from taking over our society is in this book! Check out a couple of the blurbs:


Amid all the public discussion about the true nature and derivation of the global jihad threat, too little attention has been paid to the myriad ways in which Islamic law is actually not benign or good for individuals or societies, but in its pure form actively detrimental to the wellbeing of both. In this important book, Fr. Mario Alexis Portella illustrates how Sharia contravenes natural rights in numerous particulars, and causes whole classes of people (notably women and non-Muslims) lasting harm. All Catholic leaders engaged in “dialogue” with Muslims should prepare for that “dialogue” by reading and studying this book. — Robert Spencer, author of the New York Times bestsellers The Politically Incorrect Guide to Islam (and the Crusades) and The Truth About Muhammad

“If you have friends or family members who still think Islam is a religion of peace, give them this book. Mario Portella delves into the Quran, Islamic law, and the history of Islam to show that hostility toward unbelievers, and violence against them, are constants in Islamic doctrine and practice. Find out what the West has let itself in for by allowing Muslim migrants in huge numbers to settle in Western countries — read Islam – Religion of Peace?: The Violation of Natural Rights and Western Cover-up.” — Pamela Geller, author of Fatwa: Hunted In America and President of the American Freedom Defense Initiative

Rev. Mario shows us why we cannot give in to the pressures of political correctness by remaining silent in this struggle. We must shine a spotlight on extremists, recognize the challenges they pose, and fight back in the arena of ideas. — Rev. Majed El Shafie, President & Founder,

Book is available on Amazon:

Barnes & Noble:

WestBow Press: